For
really serious tyres I've been admiring Mickey Thompson Baja...they look great! Dunno bout puncture resistance though.
Not much of a range for 15" & might be a struggle to fit with 16". I think your OEM tyres are 215/65/16?
The
Mickey Thompson Baja ATZ 5-rib has a 30/9.50R15LT (OD 744mm) & a LT225/75R16 (OD 747).
I dont really understand this style code though, other than its a 30" tyre.
The
Mickey Thompson Baja STZ looks great, but again the smallest tyre is P235/70R16 (OD 737)
The
Mickey Thompson Baja MTZ looks wicked & has a 31/10.50R15LT (OD 782) but the smallest 16" is LT265/75R16 (32/10.5R16LT) (OD 813)
Yokohama
Geolandar A/T-S have good puncture resistance & a
factory puncture warranty but maybe arent "serious" enough for your needs. Other than that the new
Cooper Discoverer AT3 or
BFG A/T or
BFG M/T may be your best choice.
But those Mickey Ts.....